APET vs. PETG Packaging Materials – What's the Difference?

Sep 19, 2023 Leave a message

 


If you work in packaging, you've likely come across two common materials: APET and PETG. They sound similar, and they are both clear, recyclable plastics. But they have different properties, and choosing the wrong one for your product can lead to cracking, poor clarity, or higher costs.

 

This guide explains the key differences simply and clearly – so you can make the right choice.

 


1. What Are They?


Material            Full Name                      What It Is



APET                 Amorphous                   Polyethylene Terephthalate Unmodified PET – the same material used in water bottles



PETG                Polyethylene                 Terephthalate Glycol PET modified with glycol for better flexibility



Both are clear, recyclable thermoplastics – but their chemical structures give them different performance characteristics.

 


 

2. Quick Comparison


Factor                                     APET                                                                  PETG



Clarity                                    Excellent – crystal clear                             Excellent – crystal clear



Impact resistance             Good                                                                  Better – more flexible



Tensile strength                 Higher                                                               Lower



Chemical resistance         Excellent                                                          Good



Heat resistance                   Higher (up to ~70°C)                                   Lower (up to ~60°C)



Bending / flexing               Can crack under stress                               Will not crack – more durable



Thermoforming                 Easy                                                                     Slightly easier



Recyclability                        Highly recyclable (#1 PET)                        Recyclable but less common



Cost                                         Lower                                                                 Higher



Common uses                    Blister packs, clamshells, trays                Medical packaging, displays, electronics



3. Key Differences – What Matters for Packaging


A. Flexibility and Impact Resistance


This is the most important difference.

 

Material                Flexibility                                                                             When to Choose



APET                     Rigid – can crack under impact or bending           For standard packaging that doesn't need to flex



PETG                     Flexible – bends without cracking                             For packaging that will be handled, dropped, or flexed



Example: If you're packaging heavy items or products that may be dropped, PETG is safer – it won't shatter or crack like APET.

 

B. Chemical Resistance


Material          Resistance to                                                                                 Best For



APET                Excellent against oils, acids, and alcohol                          Food packaging, cosmetic containers



PETG               Good – but less resistant to strong solvents                     General packaging, displays



Example: For food items with high oil content (e.g., fried snacks), APET is a better choice.

 

C. Heat Resistance


Material          Max Service                      Temperature Best For



APET               ~70°C                                    Warm-fill applications, ambient storage



PETG              ~60°C                                    Cold to room-temperature products



Example: For products that may be stored in warm conditions, APET holds up better.

 

D. Thermoforming (Manufacturing)


Material                     Thermoforming                                                         Note



APET                           Easy, but requires precise control                     Can crystallize if overheated



PETG                           Very easy, wider processing window               More forgiving during production



Example: PETG is easier to work with in manufacturing – especially for complex shapes.

 


 

4. Application Guide


Product                                          Type Recommended                                              Material Why



Blister packs                                 APET or PETG                                    APET for rigid; PETG for impact-prone items



Food trays                                     APET                                                      Better chemical and heat resistance



Medical packaging                    PETG                                                      Needs to withstand sterilization without cracking



Clamshells                                    APET                                                      Rigid and clear – ideal for retail displays



Electronic displays                    PETG                                                      Flexible, won't crack during handling



Cosmetic containers                APET                                                       Good barrier and clear appearance



Heavy product packaging     PETG                                                       Absorbs impact without breaking



Cold storage packaging         PETG                                                        Stays flexible at low temperatures



5. Quick Summary – Which Should You Choose?


If Your Priority Is...                                                           Choose...



Lower cost                                                                          APET



High impact resistance (no cracking)                     PETG



Food contact with oils/acids                                      APET



Medical or sterile packaging                                      PETG



Highest clarity                                                                  Both are excellent



Recycling ease                                                                  APET (#1 PET widely recycled)



Complex shapes / thermoforming                          PETG (easier to form)



Warm-fill applications                                                  APET



6. Safety and Regulatory


Material                  Food Contact Safe?                                    Medical Grade?



APET                       ✅ FDA-approved                                        Limited



PETG                       ✅ FDA-approved                                       ✅ Yes – widely used in medical



Both are BPA-free and phthalate-free – safe for food and consumer use.

 


 

7. Environmental Considerations


Material                    Recyclability                                                     Sustainability



APET                         #1 PET – widely recyclable                         Good – same as water bottles



PETG                         Less commonly recycled                            Improving – but not as widespread



If recycling infrastructure matters to your end-users, APET has the edge.

 


 

8. Cost Comparison


Material                                   Relative Cost



APET                          Lower (standard grade)



PETG                         Higher (glycol additive increases cost)



PETG typically costs 10–30% more than APET. The price difference is justified when impact resistance is critical.

 


 

Final Recommendation


Scenario                                                                                         Best Choice



Standard retail packaging, cost-sensitive                        APET



Heavy or fragile products, risk of dropping                     PETG



Food packaging with oils or acids                                       APET



Medical or pharmaceutical packaging                              PETG



Complex shapes or tight tolerances                                   PETG



Eco-friendly / recyclable priority                                         APET